Yes, you may be right. I had the oppurtunity of leading the NUST team to visit the universities of the Irish Republic a few years back and realized that they have been taken for a ride by their Irish American Consultants who ended up with good business for American Companies rather than creating indigenous Irish companies after all that investments in money and human resource. The same could be said about Malaysia where billions of US Dollars have been spent on creating the Infra-structure of SIRIM, MIMOS and several Technology Parks since the last 15 years and there has hardly been any Malaysian Company with its indigenous technology competing at the global level.
So, we have to learn from all these blunders and take evasive actions. Innovation cannot be done either in a jiffy or by throwing the money. It can only be achieved incrementally with a right Action Plan and a whole generation has to be kept in focus to achieve it and for God sake lets keep the half cooked and half baked foreign consultants out of this loop as it would only end up with more loans on our future generations.
To: pakgrid@yahoogroups.com
From: ishtiaq.ahmad@gmail.com
Date: Fri, 26 Aug 2011 11:50:59 +0200
Subject: [pakgrid] Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
So, we have to learn from all these blunders and take evasive actions. Innovation cannot be done either in a jiffy or by throwing the money. It can only be achieved incrementally with a right Action Plan and a whole generation has to be kept in focus to achieve it and for God sake lets keep the half cooked and half baked foreign consultants out of this loop as it would only end up with more loans on our future generations.
EMSQUARE
To: pakgrid@yahoogroups.com
From: ishtiaq.ahmad@gmail.com
Date: Fri, 26 Aug 2011 11:50:59 +0200
Subject: [pakgrid] Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
May be we can do it right and learn form their mistakes
Mojgan Naghavi1 & Derek Walsh2
Journal name: Nature
Volume: 476,
Page: 399
Date published: (25 August 2011)
DOI: doi:10.1038/476399b
Published online 24 August 2011
You highlight China's scientific investment drive (Nature 476, 5; 2011). This is a reminder that nations with little experience of modern large-scale investment in science may be jumping into ill-planned knowledge-economy ventures that could have serious long-term consequences.
Take Ireland, for example. An explosion in scientific investment quickly attracted many scientists to the country and saw it climb up the international scientific rankings. Now fundamental flaws in the Irish system are showing up as the funding fades.
Having been recruited from the United States by Science Foundation Ireland (SFI), we were shocked to discover how poorly planned and disjointed the research system seems to be in Ireland. The SFI does not make clear to either the host institution or the recruited scientist that their investment in the recruit is short-term. One learns after recruitment that universities often do not want to employ researchers for longer than 4 years, to avoid commitments under the European Union's fixed-term workers' contract.
Continuous changes by the SFI to core funding programmes, combined with cronyism in the Irish university system, mean that the career structures and support needed to build a stable research environment are missing.
Many Irish researchers are discontented; some have left or are leaving the country (D. Ahlstrom The Irish Times 17 December 2010). Ireland seems not to realize that it is scientists who drive research, focusing instead on large capital investments in impressive research buildings that bolster the image of an economic strategy.
Many countries try to emulate the US academic system. This is based on money, yes, but also on supporting talent through the tenure track. Ignore this and valuable government finances will be wasted and the careers of young scientists will hit a dead end. Developing a knowledge economy requires some knowledge of how to do it properly.
Nature article: Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
The address is: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v476/n7361/full/476399b.html
Mojgan Naghavi1 & Derek Walsh2
Journal name: Nature
Volume: 476,
Page: 399
Date published: (25 August 2011)
DOI: doi:10.1038/476399b
Published online 24 August 2011
You highlight China's scientific investment drive (Nature 476, 5; 2011). This is a reminder that nations with little experience of modern large-scale investment in science may be jumping into ill-planned knowledge-economy ventures that could have serious long-term consequences.
Take Ireland, for example. An explosion in scientific investment quickly attracted many scientists to the country and saw it climb up the international scientific rankings. Now fundamental flaws in the Irish system are showing up as the funding fades.
Having been recruited from the United States by Science Foundation Ireland (SFI), we were shocked to discover how poorly planned and disjointed the research system seems to be in Ireland. The SFI does not make clear to either the host institution or the recruited scientist that their investment in the recruit is short-term. One learns after recruitment that universities often do not want to employ researchers for longer than 4 years, to avoid commitments under the European Union's fixed-term workers' contract.
Continuous changes by the SFI to core funding programmes, combined with cronyism in the Irish university system, mean that the career structures and support needed to build a stable research environment are missing.
Many Irish researchers are discontented; some have left or are leaving the country (D. Ahlstrom The Irish Times 17 December 2010). Ireland seems not to realize that it is scientists who drive research, focusing instead on large capital investments in impressive research buildings that bolster the image of an economic strategy.
Many countries try to emulate the US academic system. This is based on money, yes, but also on supporting talent through the tenure track. Ignore this and valuable government finances will be wasted and the careers of young scientists will hit a dead end. Developing a knowledge economy requires some knowledge of how to do it properly.
Nature article: Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
The address is: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v476/n7361/full/476399b.html
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: natureapp@nature.com on behalf of iahmad@amc.uva.nl <iahmad@amc.uva.nl>
Date: Fri, Aug 26, 2011 at 11:35 AM
Subject: Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
To: ishtiaq.ahmad@gmail.com
From: natureapp@nature.com on behalf of iahmad@amc.uva.nl <iahmad@amc.uva.nl>
Date: Fri, Aug 26, 2011 at 11:35 AM
Subject: Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
To: ishtiaq.ahmad@gmail.com
Nature article: Research funding: Learn from Ireland's knowledge economy
The address is: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v476/n7361/full/476399b.html
The address is: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v476/n7361/full/476399b.html
__._,_.___
.
__,_._,___
No comments:
Post a Comment